FourFineFriends.com / December 10, 2025
Artistry, Coffee, and the Best Sugar Bliss in New York State
Let’s be real for a second. How rare is it these days to find a genuine, honest-to-goodness candy store right on Main Street? We’re not talking about a mall kiosk or a grocery store aisle. We’re talking about the kind of place that used to anchor every downtown in America—a place where community, sugar, and nostalgia meet.
They are a dying breed, which is why our hearts skipped a beat when we walked into the Keuka Candy Emporium in Penn Yan, New York.
Meeting the Artist Behind the Apron
One of the highlights of our trip was getting to chat with Stacey, the owner and creative force behind the counter. He told us the Emporium has been a staple here for 12 years, but if you watch him work, you’d think he just opened yesterday.
Stacey is still genuinely excited about his artistry every single day. You can see it in the way he talks about the chocolate and the care he puts into the shop. It’s rare to find that kind of passion a decade in, and it makes the candy taste that much sweeter.
The “Largest Retro Candy Store in New York”
You read that title right. This isn’t just a little shop; it holds the title for the Largest Retro Candy Store in New York State. Walking the aisles is literally a treasure hunt. If you remember eating it in 1975, 1985, or 1995, chances are Stacey has it on a shelf here.
Not Just for Browsing
We didn’t just grab candy and run; we stayed for the experience. The Emporium has evolved into a full-blown destination:
- The Sips: They are brewing up incredible specialty coffee drinks for the adults who need a caffeine kick to keep up with the sugar rush.
- The Classics: We treated ourselves to old-time root beer floats and ice cream treats that tasted exactly like summer vacation.
- The Venue: Here is a pro-tip we picked up—they have a large rental space available! If you are planning a party or an event and want a backdrop that screams “fun,” this is the spot.
The Verdict
The Keuka Candy Emporium is proof that Main Street magic is still alive and well. Whether you want to sip a latte, throw a party, or just chat with a chocolatier who truly loves his craft, you need to get to Penn Yan. Learn More at: https://www.keukacandyemporium.com/
