“Characterizing Indivisible and local Democrats as outsiders or “hyper-activists” ignores reality”
By JJ Cain, Allegany County
Linda Fanton’s recent opinion claims grassroots movements win elections, implying progressive protests against President Trump and Congressman Nick Langworthy are merely “Astroturf.” This conveniently ignores that genuine grassroots movements have consistently driven social progress, from civil rights to labor reform, often against significant opposition and mischaracterization by establishment voices.
The massive vote count in favor of Trump and Langworthy in the Southern Tier isn’t proof of universal agreement; rather, it highlights deep divides. True grassroots movements, like Hands Off Protest, rise precisely because significant segments of our communities feel threatened by policies and rhetoric from leaders who openly dismiss democracy, accountability, and basic human rights.
Characterizing Indivisible and local Democrats as outsiders or “hyper-activists” ignores reality. These are neighbors, friends, teachers, and healthcare workers genuinely concerned about protecting democracy, promoting fairness, and ensuring elected officials are accountable. Labeling them “dark money groups” deflects from real issues like Langworthy’s and Trump’s troubling silence on income inequality, systemic racism, women’s rights, LGBTQ+ rights, and climate change.
Progressive protests aren’t the voice of “failed Democrat ideas,” they’re a call to action for a just, accountable, and compassionate society. Langworthy and Trump’s electoral success isn’t permission to silence dissent; it’s a signal that meaningful opposition and engagement are more necessary than ever. Grassroots democracy thrives on debate, protest, and the relentless pursuit of justice—not quiet obedience.
We citizens of the Southern Tier deserve better than divisive rhetoric and deflection. Democracy demands courage, accountability, and a government that genuinely serves all its people—not just those who shout the loudest about “silent majorities.”
